SC upholds dismissal of ruling vs disclosure of Duterte’s medical records

SC upholds dismissal of ruling vs disclosure of Duterte’s medical records

By Rockwell Santos

LACK of merit.

This was the decision made by the Supreme Court as it upheld the dismissal of case seeking the disclosure of President Rodrigo Duterte’s health records from the time he assumed the presidency.

In a four-page resolution dated Sept. 8 and released Friday, the SC through Clerk of Court Edgar Aricheta said the court’s resolution last May dismissing the extremely urgent petition for mandamus filed by lawyer Dino de Leon is deemed final.

No further pleadings or motions shall be entertained in the case, the tribunal said.

“In view of the petitioner’s failure to allege a prima facie case for mandamus, the Court found it unnecessary to address the other matters raised in the petition. In the same vein, there is no reason for the Court to belabor the point considering that the instant motion presents no substantial argument to support a case for mandamus, much less to warrant the reversal of the resolution,” the tribunal added.

The high court junked, in May, the petition filed by de Leon seeking to compel Malacañang to disclose all the medical results and health bulletins of the President and to compel him to undergo “confirmatory medical examinations” for lack of merit.

The court noted that in recent months, the President has been visibly holding regular Cabinet meetings.

This, the SC said, belies the “petitioner’s insinuation that the President is suffering from serious illnesses”.

De Leon filed the petition last April 13 claiming the President has been absent from engagements and also had prolonged absences from public view.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.


Welcome to Metro Sun, an online news website where stories inspire community engagement and digitally fuelled actions for economic change in the Philippines or any associated countries based on current events.


Some links on this page are affiliate links in which we earn a commission from sales of items we recommend at no extra cost to you. And as an Amazon Associate, we also earn from qualifying purchases linking to any of their websites. Please read our Disclaimer linked below.

Scroll to Top